Archive for January, 2008

Behavior-Based Internet Advertising: Who Is Watching You?

Have you ever been surfing the web and come upon Internet advertising that provides a direct solution for something that you’ve been researching lately? Did you think that it might be related to your computer cookies, or did you chalk it up to serendipity?

The fact is, it almost certainly wasn’t a coincidence. Behavior-based Internet advertising is a relatively new and very powerful way for advertisers to get their message in front of potential buyers that they know to be qualified. The question is, how do they know that the surfer is qualified?

The advertisers know this because the Internet advertising network is tracking the surfers’ online activity. With tracking, advertisers know what sites you like. They know what searches you make. They have profiled you, and, unlike in real life, profiling on the web is AOK — so far.

Check Your Computer for Cookies

Before we get into the legal issues involved, perhaps a further definition of the technology is in order. Most (but not all) behavioral Internet advertising is based on computer “cookies.” These computer cookies are tiny files that are placed on your machine when you visit certain websites. In the simplest form, you go to a web page. An advertiser has a blank spot, or placeholder, for a banner ad. But instead of serving up just any banner ad, the advertiser parses through your computer for cookies to discover your likes and dislikes, and then you are fed Internet advertising based on your online behavior.

For some people, this is no big deal. They like Internet advertising to be targeted toward them, and they don’t mind computer cookies. For others, it’s a little Orwellian and creepy. This leads us to the great debate.

Opt-in or Opt-out?

One big question to be resolved is whether ultimately this type of Internet advertising will be “opt-in” (meaning that a user has to sign up in order to receive targeted ads) or “opt-out” (meaning that a user will receive targeted ads unless they specifically ask not to).

It shouldn’t surprise anyone to know which side the advertisers are on. If governmental regulators eventually require that all Internet advertising be “opt-in”, the industry will be severely restricted. My guess is that it would relegate behavior-based Internet advertising to a fringe player in the online marketing world.

The privacy advocates, naturally, are on the other side of the fence. The vast majority of people assume that their online activity is not being tracked, they say. Why should they have to take a specific action in order to remove computer cookies and to not be tracked and profiled?

A Do Not Track List?

Recently, a group of nine consumer advocate groups proposed the idea of a “Do Not Track” list for Internet advertising, which would work in a similar fashion as the “Do Not Call” list works today. Naturally, this is an “Opt-out” scenario, but because of the attention that the formation of such a list would bring, it may be a suitable compromise between advertiser and advocate.

How to Prevent Being Tracked

It is fairly easy to prevent being tracked by advertisers. You simply prevent your machine from accepting computer cookies. Go to START, SETTINGS, CONTROL PANEL and click on INTERNET OPTIONS then the PRIVACY tab. (Note that these instructions assume you are working with a Windows XP system. The procedure will be similar, however, for other operating systems.) Slide the bar all the way to the top to where it says “Block All Cookies.”

However, you should be aware that this change may limit your Internet experience. Some websites will not display properly (or at all) if you do not accept computer cookies. In my experience, at least one of the top five search engines will not work at all. Other engines have limited functionality when you block Internet advertising.

Even if you do manage to turn off your computer cookies, don’t rest easy just yet.

The Newest Technology

Recently, it was announced that a Silicon Valley startup named NebuAd has created a new technology that does not require computer cookies. Under the NebuAd model, the company teams up directly with service providers and installs equipment directly at their facilities that allows them to track the behavior of individuals on the web, even if their machine does not accept computer cookies. This, of course, requires Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to embrace the new technology; naturally, they are given a piece of the Internet advertising revenue that is generated. Whether or not any of the major players embrace this technology will probably depend largely on public outcry, or lack thereof. Of course, if this does become the newest behavioral targeting standard, we will return again to the question of “Opt-in” or “Opt-out.”

Conclusion

The future of this approach to Internet advertising is unclear, and will depend largely on public education and reaction. Will people see value in receiving targeted ads, even if it means that somewhere there is an “anonymous” profile of them sitting on a server? Will they feel outraged and push for a total ban? It’s hard to say.

Will this new approach be the death of the Internet as we know it? Probably not. But it should at least be interesting.


Behavior-Based Internet Advertising: Who Is Watching You?

Have you ever been surfing the web and come upon Internet advertising that provides a direct solution for something that you’ve been researching lately? Did you think that it might be related to your computer cookies, or did you chalk it up to serendipity?

The fact is, it almost certainly wasn’t a coincidence. Behavior-based Internet advertising is a relatively new and very powerful way for advertisers to get their message in front of potential buyers that they know to be qualified. The question is, how do they know that the surfer is qualified?

The advertisers know this because the Internet advertising network is tracking the surfers’ online activity. With tracking, advertisers know what sites you like. They know what searches you make. They have profiled you, and, unlike in real life, profiling on the web is AOK — so far.

Check Your Computer for Cookies

Before we get into the legal issues involved, perhaps a further definition of the technology is in order. Most (but not all) behavioral Internet advertising is based on computer “cookies.” These computer cookies are tiny files that are placed on your machine when you visit certain websites. In the simplest form, you go to a web page. An advertiser has a blank spot, or placeholder, for a banner ad. But instead of serving up just any banner ad, the advertiser parses through your computer for cookies to discover your likes and dislikes, and then you are fed Internet advertising based on your online behavior.

For some people, this is no big deal. They like Internet advertising to be targeted toward them, and they don’t mind computer cookies. For others, it’s a little Orwellian and creepy. This leads us to the great debate.

Opt-in or Opt-out?

One big question to be resolved is whether ultimately this type of Internet advertising will be “opt-in” (meaning that a user has to sign up in order to receive targeted ads) or “opt-out” (meaning that a user will receive targeted ads unless they specifically ask not to).

It shouldn’t surprise anyone to know which side the advertisers are on. If governmental regulators eventually require that all Internet advertising be “opt-in”, the industry will be severely restricted. My guess is that it would relegate behavior-based Internet advertising to a fringe player in the online marketing world.

The privacy advocates, naturally, are on the other side of the fence. The vast majority of people assume that their online activity is not being tracked, they say. Why should they have to take a specific action in order to remove computer cookies and to not be tracked and profiled?

A Do Not Track List?

Recently, a group of nine consumer advocate groups proposed the idea of a “Do Not Track” list for Internet advertising, which would work in a similar fashion as the “Do Not Call” list works today. Naturally, this is an “Opt-out” scenario, but because of the attention that the formation of such a list would bring, it may be a suitable compromise between advertiser and advocate.

How to Prevent Being Tracked

It is fairly easy to prevent being tracked by advertisers. You simply prevent your machine from accepting computer cookies. Go to START, SETTINGS, CONTROL PANEL and click on INTERNET OPTIONS then the PRIVACY tab. (Note that these instructions assume you are working with a Windows XP system. The procedure will be similar, however, for other operating systems.) Slide the bar all the way to the top to where it says “Block All Cookies.”

However, you should be aware that this change may limit your Internet experience. Some websites will not display properly (or at all) if you do not accept computer cookies. In my experience, at least one of the top five search engines will not work at all. Other engines have limited functionality when you block Internet advertising.

Even if you do manage to turn off your computer cookies, don’t rest easy just yet.

The Newest Technology

Recently, it was announced that a Silicon Valley startup named NebuAd has created a new technology that does not require computer cookies. Under the NebuAd model, the company teams up directly with service providers and installs equipment directly at their facilities that allows them to track the behavior of individuals on the web, even if their machine does not accept computer cookies. This, of course, requires Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to embrace the new technology; naturally, they are given a piece of the Internet advertising revenue that is generated. Whether or not any of the major players embrace this technology will probably depend largely on public outcry, or lack thereof. Of course, if this does become the newest behavioral targeting standard, we will return again to the question of “Opt-in” or “Opt-out.”

Conclusion

The future of this approach to Internet advertising is unclear, and will depend largely on public education and reaction. Will people see value in receiving targeted ads, even if it means that somewhere there is an “anonymous” profile of them sitting on a server? Will they feel outraged and push for a total ban? It’s hard to say.

Will this new approach be the death of the Internet as we know it? Probably not. But it should at least be interesting.


Behavior-Based Internet Advertising: Who Is Watching You?

Have you ever been surfing the web and come upon Internet advertising that provides a direct solution for something that you’ve been researching lately? Did you think that it might be related to your computer cookies, or did you chalk it up to serendipity?

The fact is, it almost certainly wasn’t a coincidence. Behavior-based Internet advertising is a relatively new and very powerful way for advertisers to get their message in front of potential buyers that they know to be qualified. The question is, how do they know that the surfer is qualified?

The advertisers know this because the Internet advertising network is tracking the surfers’ online activity. With tracking, advertisers know what sites you like. They know what searches you make. They have profiled you, and, unlike in real life, profiling on the web is AOK — so far.

Check Your Computer for Cookies

Before we get into the legal issues involved, perhaps a further definition of the technology is in order. Most (but not all) behavioral Internet advertising is based on computer “cookies.” These computer cookies are tiny files that are placed on your machine when you visit certain websites. In the simplest form, you go to a web page. An advertiser has a blank spot, or placeholder, for a banner ad. But instead of serving up just any banner ad, the advertiser parses through your computer for cookies to discover your likes and dislikes, and then you are fed Internet advertising based on your online behavior.

For some people, this is no big deal. They like Internet advertising to be targeted toward them, and they don’t mind computer cookies. For others, it’s a little Orwellian and creepy. This leads us to the great debate.

Opt-in or Opt-out?

One big question to be resolved is whether ultimately this type of Internet advertising will be “opt-in” (meaning that a user has to sign up in order to receive targeted ads) or “opt-out” (meaning that a user will receive targeted ads unless they specifically ask not to).

It shouldn’t surprise anyone to know which side the advertisers are on. If governmental regulators eventually require that all Internet advertising be “opt-in”, the industry will be severely restricted. My guess is that it would relegate behavior-based Internet advertising to a fringe player in the online marketing world.

The privacy advocates, naturally, are on the other side of the fence. The vast majority of people assume that their online activity is not being tracked, they say. Why should they have to take a specific action in order to remove computer cookies and to not be tracked and profiled?

A Do Not Track List?

Recently, a group of nine consumer advocate groups proposed the idea of a “Do Not Track” list for Internet advertising, which would work in a similar fashion as the “Do Not Call” list works today. Naturally, this is an “Opt-out” scenario, but because of the attention that the formation of such a list would bring, it may be a suitable compromise between advertiser and advocate.

How to Prevent Being Tracked

It is fairly easy to prevent being tracked by advertisers. You simply prevent your machine from accepting computer cookies. Go to START, SETTINGS, CONTROL PANEL and click on INTERNET OPTIONS then the PRIVACY tab. (Note that these instructions assume you are working with a Windows XP system. The procedure will be similar, however, for other operating systems.) Slide the bar all the way to the top to where it says “Block All Cookies.”

However, you should be aware that this change may limit your Internet experience. Some websites will not display properly (or at all) if you do not accept computer cookies. In my experience, at least one of the top five search engines will not work at all. Other engines have limited functionality when you block Internet advertising.

Even if you do manage to turn off your computer cookies, don’t rest easy just yet.

The Newest Technology

Recently, it was announced that a Silicon Valley startup named NebuAd has created a new technology that does not require computer cookies. Under the NebuAd model, the company teams up directly with service providers and installs equipment directly at their facilities that allows them to track the behavior of individuals on the web, even if their machine does not accept computer cookies. This, of course, requires Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to embrace the new technology; naturally, they are given a piece of the Internet advertising revenue that is generated. Whether or not any of the major players embrace this technology will probably depend largely on public outcry, or lack thereof. Of course, if this does become the newest behavioral targeting standard, we will return again to the question of “Opt-in” or “Opt-out.”

Conclusion

The future of this approach to Internet advertising is unclear, and will depend largely on public education and reaction. Will people see value in receiving targeted ads, even if it means that somewhere there is an “anonymous” profile of them sitting on a server? Will they feel outraged and push for a total ban? It’s hard to say.

Will this new approach be the death of the Internet as we know it? Probably not. But it should at least be interesting.


Motorola tries to quarantine handset unit

Motorola’s handset unit is a sick patient. The solution: Quarantine it or maybe send it packing.
That’s the big takeaway of Motorola’s disclosure that it is “is exploring the structural and strategic realignment of its businesses to better equip its Mobile Devices business to recapture global market leadership and to enhance shareholder value.”
In English, Motorola is […]


BTL podcast: Demo 08, Yahoo woes, Amazon’s moves and more…

This week on the Between the Lines podcast, I give a wrap up from my trip to the Demo 08 conference, where 77 products were introduced. We also discuss some of the recent earnings and restructuring news from Yahoo. Larry ponders if we would be able to recognize what Amazon becomes ten years hence.
You can […]


Gartner’s top 10 predictions on IT futures

Gartner researchers have identified 10 areas that IT professionals should pay attention to this year.
Gartner: By 2011, Apple will double its U.S. and Western Europe unit market share in computers.
Our take: Gartner correctly assesses that Apple’s gains are a reflection of failure by competitors to create a more compelling user experience. It’s not the just […]


Two blogs are better than one

In case you can’t get enough of me here, I thought I’d direct your attention over to Simply Put, the second blog that I’ve been actively contributing to.

Google’s quarter falls short of expectations; Social networking not monetizing well

Google on Thursday reported fourth quarter net income of $1.21 billion, or $3.79 a share, on revenue of $4.83 billion, up 51 percent from a year ago. Excluding charges Google reported earnings of $4.43 a share. All of those figures missed Wall Street estimates.
According to Thomson Financial, Google was expected to report a fourth quarter […]


SEOs Fight Fat - A Different Kind of SEO Contest

SEO contests are nothing new. Every few months someone pops up with some randomly generated phrase and a pile of prizes so aspiring search engine optimizers can go head to head in a race for top rankings. But when Donna Fontenot (DazzlinDonna) approached me about her latest idea for an SEO contest, I couldn’t resist. This time around, Donna has recruited about a dozen search marketers to go head to head in a two-month, live blogged weight loss competition a la’ “The Biggest Loser.” The cool part? It’s all about raising money for charities.

Dubbed SEOs Fight Fat, the contest pits Donna Fontenot, Debra Mastaler, me, Nathania Johnson and Scottie Claiborne against each other on the women’s side and Aaron Wall, Jim Boykin, Simon Heseltine, David Wallace, Ben Cook and Jeff Quipp against each other on the men’s side.

The goal is to lose the highest percentage of body weight by the end of the two months. Whichever man and woman come out on top will go head to head in a vote. The ultimate winner gets the entire “pot” of pledged donations for the charity of their choice. Long time Search Engine Guide readers won’t be surprised to hear I’m playing for the HMBANA milk banks, an organization I got involved with when my daughter Elnora was a baby. I donated 27 gallons of milk to my local bank that first year and have used my hobby site The Lactivist to spread awareness and raise several thousand dollars for the bank here in Ohio.

You can follow along at the site, or subscribe to direct feeds for any of the players. If you’d like to get involved with a pledge, you can do that as well. If you’re feeling really generous, you can become a sponsor of the entire site for $2000 or a sponsor of an individual player for $500. These sponsors will have a 125×125 ad displayed either across the site, or on all posts made by their sponsored player. Search Engine Guide reader Mike Dorausch of Planet Chiropractic has generously come on board to sponsor my area of the blog as has Robert for the upcoming Small Business Marketing Unleashed conference. The more the merrier on this one folks, so stop by the site and get involved!


Part One: From Twits to Tweeple, Why I Embraced Twitter and You Should Too

It’s no secret I’m skeptical when it comes to social media fads. I’ve never been a fan of Digg, I STILL don’t get the allure of Facebook and I’m more than a little tired of the flood of invites in my email whenever people find “the next big thing.” That’s probably why I dismissed Twitter as a fairly silly idea that was indicative of our need to now broadcast each and every detail of our lives to the world. (Because really, do you care that personX just got home from the gym?)

That said, a few friends in the industry finally convinced me to log on just after the first of the year. After all, you shouldn’t knock it until you try it right? I’ve been “trying it” for a month now. I have to admit; I was absolutely wrong. Sure, there are folks who flood Twitter with mindless drivel, but Twitter also features a vibrant community leveraging the tool in interesting ways and bringing people together the way only really good technology can. I’d vowed to give Twitter a month to win me over. That month has ended and Twitter wins.

Now that I’ve had time to really dive into the service, experiement with it and learn some of the finer details, I figured it’s about time I wrote a Seach Engine Guide style guide to the service. This multi-part series will cover everything from how to get an account and get people following you to the finer points of twitter marketing and networking. It’s not a service that will be worth the time to everyone, but it’s certainly proven itself to have practical application for me.

What is Twitter?

twitterlogo.gifTwitter has been called a form of “micro-blogging.” I get where people are going with this, but I’m really not sure it’s the best description. In the month I’ve been using it, I see it more as an open chat room. The basic idea of Twitter is to allow users to broadcast short messages (known as “tweets”) to anyone who opts to receive them. It’s a free service that was designed with mobile phones in mind, but allows users to connect via the Twitter website, IM applications and any number of Twitter applications as well.

People use Twitter as a form of communication. Think of it as an instant message that goes out to a ton of people at once. If you want to let your friends know you’re headed to your favorite hang-out tonight, you can shoot them all a quick message without having to send a dozen emails. If you want feedback on an idea, you can tap into your network to ask a quick question. If you simply want to learn a little more about people you’ve heard of online, you can follow their tweets and “eavesdrop” in an acceptable way. In fact, I’ve found quite a few practical reasons to use Twitter, which I’ll outline later in the series.

Getting An Account

It couldn’t be simpler to start Twittering. You simply need to head to the Twitter web site and look for the “Get Started - Join” button.

jointwitter.gif

You then follow a pretty standard simple sign-up process to establish your screen name and associated email address.

twittername.gif

It’s a good idea to give some thought to your screen name when signing up. You may want to go with your full name (for example, I tweet as “JenniferLaycock“) or you may want to carry on the branding of your web site. (Robert tweets as “SmallBizAnswers.”) Either route makes it a lot easier for people to find and follow you than it would be if you signed up as “randomname1234.”

Once you’ve set up your account, you’ll need to get hooked up with some other users. After all, if you’re just out there sending messages to yourself, Twitter is going to get pretty boring. Twitter helps you find your friends as part of the registration process. You’ll have to hand over temporary access to your email account, but it can be a quick way to find people you know on Twitter.

twittemail.gif

Once Twitter scans your accounts, they’ll return a list of your contacts already using Twitter. You can select some or all and then have Twitter automatically load them into your followers and following lists.

twittercontact.gif

Twitter will also generate a list of your contacts who do not have Twitter accounts and will allow you to select the ones you’d like to invite to the system. If you’re the last of your friends to join Twitter, this will be a short list. For most of the world, this is going to be a very long list. (Tip: Don’t spam everyone you know with a Twitter invite. Take the time to browse through this list and to invite only the people you have a true interest in following and who you think might have a true interest in following you.)

Personalizing Your Profile

twitterpanel.gifOnce you’ve set up your account and sent emails out to your friends, you’ll be taken back to the Twitter home page with an invitation to join the conversation. Before you do this, I’d suggest you look over to the right side of the screen at your Twitter control panel. That box will show your avatar (which starts as a default set of eyes on a brown background) and your screen name. It also tracks how many people you are following and are following you, how many direct messages you’ve received and how many tweets you’ve posted.

If you look at the top right spot on the box, you’ll notice a link that says “your profile.”

Don’t be surprised if you see a page that simply says “haven’t updated yet!” when you click this link.

twittersurprise.gif

The first time I saw it, I wondered if I had to make a post before I could update my profile information, but that isn’t the case. Simply click on the “add a photo” box next to your screen name and you’ll quickly shift into the full profile area of the site.

twitterprofile.gif

Once you’re in the profile update area, you’ll be asked to upload an image to use as your avatar. You might upload a photo of yourself, or you might want to stick with your company logo. Keep in mind this image will show up next to your posts and will also show up when someone views a list of who a Twitter user is following. (Tip: An avatar that stands out from the crowd can really catch someone’s eye when they’re looking to see who a particular user follows.)

Next, you’ll need to create a brief bio and list your web site URL. On this screen, you also have the option of making your tweets private. This means your tweets will only show up for approved followers. You’ll have to take the time to manually approve everyone who wants to follow you, but it does give a nice level of privacy to anyone worried about strangers reading their tweets.

twitteraccount.gif

Once you’ve let people know a little more about who you are, you’ll need to let Twitter know how you’d like to receive updates. Sure, you can go to the web site to read them, but believe me, that’s going to get old really fast. While there are quite a few third party applications (which I’ll cover later in this series), the two default options are via your mobile phone and via an instant messenger program.

twittermobile.gif

Getting and Sending Updates (Tweets)

Keep in mind that if you sign up to receive updates via your mobile phone, and you begin following a lot of people, you’re going to get slammed with text messages. (If you don’t have unlimited texting, you’ll also get slammed with data fees on your next bill.) A better option, if you already use an instant messenger program is to simply funnel your messages through it. (You can update to a twitter app later when you get the hang of things.)

Twitter easily integrates with GoogleTalk, LiveJournal IM, AOLIM and Jabber, so if you use any of these IM programs, you can be up and running in no time.

Once you’ve registered your mobile phone or instant messenger program, you’re setup to send tweets from any of them. On your mobile phone, you simply text your message to 40404. Twitter will use caller ID to match your phone up with your account and to broadcast it to the world. If you’re using GoogleTalk or Jabber, you’ll need to add twitter@twitter.com as a friend. If you’re on AOL’s instant messenger, you’ll add “TwitterIM” to your buddy list.

Finally, you can change the settings on your Twitter page to customize it. That way, whenever someone visits your personal Twitter site, they’ll get a taste for your personality, branding, or whatever.

For example, here’s the default Twitter page from the Search Engine Guide account I just setup:

segtwit.gif

And now my personal Twitter page which I’ve taken to adorable puppy extremes:

jentwit.gif

Keep it Short

Remember, tweets are limited to 140 characters. That’s not much in the way of sharing thoughts, but the whole point of Twitter is to communicate in thought bursts. For wordy folks like me that 140 limit can be tough, but it’s a good way to make sure you aren’t saying any more than you need to.

That’s enough to get you started with an account on Twitter. In the next article in this series, I’ll dig a little deeper into the Twitter system. I’ll explain more about the idea of “followers” and “following” and how to communicate publicly to specific twitterers. I’ll also explain how to send direct (private) messages and how to check for replies from people you aren’t following. I’ll also dig deeper into expanding your network of followers and the need to find new people to follow. For good measure, I’ll throw in a little Twitter lingo primer to help you along the way.